7 Best Comment Plugins For WordPress Compared

Comments PluginKey FeaturesDirect Link
Thrive Comments✓ New comments interface
✓ Upvotes and downvotes on comments
✓ Social accounts for comments
✓ Custom gamification badges for encouragement
No Self Pings✓ Clutter-free comments section
✓ Disables intra-blog pinging
Jetpack Comments✓ Replaces default WordPress comment form
✓ Integrated social media login options
✓ Allows users to like other comments
wpDiscuz✓ Completely replaces comments section design
✓ Clean, simple, and responsive comments form
✓ Option for commenters to subscribe to email list
WP First Letter Avatar✓ Custom avatars for users without Gravatar
✓ Avatar is set as first letter of the user’s name
✓ Compatible with bbPress and wpDiscuz
Comment Hacks✓ Redirect first-time commenters to a ‘thank you’ page
✓ Option to disallow comments based on length
✓ Forward comments to an email address
Comment Edit Lite✓ Editable comments for a limited timeframeDownload
Best WordPress Comment Plugins
  • Save

Creating an active comments section on your blog is difficult, but it is one aspect that you should work on as your blog grows.

Not only do blog comments help you engage with your readers, they can even help your site rank better on Google, at least according to my experience.

To help make it easier to create an engaging comments section on your blog, you can find lots of helpful WordPress plugins. They are, in fact, available in such huge numbers that you might feel overwhelmed trying to find the absolute best options.

To help, I’ve collected 8 of the best comment plugins for WordPress.

  1. Thrive comments
  2. No self-pings
  3. Jetpack
  4. wpDiscuz
  5. WP first letter Avatar
  6. Comment hacks
  7. Comment Edit Lite

Some of these are standalone plugins that make huge changes to your comments section, while others have smaller features that you can combine with some of the other plugins on this list.

7 Top WordPress Comment Plugins For More Engagement

1. Thrive Comments

Thrive Comments is a relatively new plugin from the stable of Thrive Themes. It is actually the exact comments system that we use here at ShoutMeLoud – so if you want to see it in action, just scroll down.

You can also read my Thrive Comments review for a more in-depth look at how the plugin works.

Thrive Comments integrates with the native WordPress comments system to add a completely new interface:

Thrive Comments for WordPress
  • Save

All your old comments will continue to work in the new interface. And if you ever deactivate the plugin, your comments will go back to the normal version displayed by your theme.

In addition to the new design, Thrive Comments adds helpful engagement-boosting features like:

  • Upvotes and downvotes on comments like Reddit (you can also just use upvotes if you don’t like the negative aspect of downvotes)
  • Social login for comments
  • Custom gamification badges for things like numbers of comments or upvotes

There are also a couple of other neat features like:

  • The option to display a custom message or offer after a user leaves a comment. Great for boosting social shares, promoting offers, or building your email list.
  • A custom moderation panel that makes it easy to control your comments
  • Analytics for your comments section

2. No Self Pings

No Self Pings is a simple plugin that helps keep your comments section free of clutter.

By default, every time that you link to an internal post on your WordPress site, your site will leave a pingback on the post that you linked to.

If you’re following good SEO principles and including lots of internal links, this can quickly start cluttering up your comments section with lots of pingbacks.

When you install and activate this plugin, you’ll get a new box when you go to Settings → Discussion that lets you enter domains to exclude from pings. By default, the plugin already includes your own domain name, but you can also add additional domain names if you want to exclude external websites:

No Self Pings
  • Save

3. Jetpack Comments

Jetpack Comments is a module in the all-purpose Jetpack plugin that replaces your blog’s comment form with a new form that lets visitors use social login to comment on your site.

It doesn’t affect how your theme displays comments – it just affects the form that your readers use to actually leave comments.

Visitors can still use the default “Email, Name, Website” method, but they also gain social login buttons for:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • WordPress.com

Another benefit that Jetpack Comments comes with is the ease of use to enable in comparison to other social login plugins. Most plugins make you create a Facebook App before you start accepting social login, but with Jetpack you just need to click a single button:

Jetpack WordPress Plugin
  • Save

Consider Jetpack if you already like how your comments section looks but just want to improve the comments form and include a social login.

4. wpDiscuz

As the name suggests, wpDiscuz aims to offer many of the same features of the Disqus comments platform in a WordPress-specific plugin.

Similar to Thrive Comments, it completely replaces your comments section design with a new one.

Here’s what the default styling looks like (they also have some other style options, though):

  • Save

In addition to the new design, here are some other features that wpDiscuz adds to your comments section:

  • Comments voting (just like Reddit and Thrive Comments)
  • Comments sorting for visitors can find new, old, or most-voted comments
  • Multi-level nested comments so that visitors can more easily follow specific comment threads
  • AJAX “Load More Comments” button so that visitors can load more comments without needing to reload the page
  • Anonymous users can edit comments (but only for a timeframe that you set)
  • Social share buttons for users to share comments
  • Option for commenters to subscribe to your email list

There are also a lot of smaller features in wpDiscuz. If you’re interested, I encourage you to check out the demo.

5. WP First Letter Avatar

By default, WordPress displays a grey “Mystery Person” avatar whenever a user doesn’t have a Gravatar image associated with their email.

WP First Letter Avatar helps you avoid a bunch of anonymous grey “Mystery Person” boxes by adding an avatar with the first letter of the commenter’s name when WordPress can’t find a Gravatar image:

WP First Letter Avatar
  • Save

While the plugin comes with its own set of letters, you can also upload your own images to use for each letter if you really want to personalize things.

6. Comment Hacks

Comment Hacks is a plugin from the Yoast SEO team that makes a few minor tweaks to how your comments section functions.

One of the neatest features is a new button in your interface that lets you email all commenters on a specific post. The admin users also get new links in the comment section to email individual commenters directly.

Another helpful feature lets you redirect first-time commenters to a special thank you page. Like Thank Me Later, you can use this to connect with your commenters and thank them or promote something. Only, with this feature, you connect on your own site rather than using the email.

Yoast Comment Hacks
  • Save

Other helpful features include:

  • Better comment notification emails
  • Option to disallow comments that are too short or too long
  • Some other basic maintenance options

7. Comment Edit Lite

How many times have you left a comment on a blog only to realize that you made a mistake right after hitting the submit button?

Comment Editing helps your visitors avoid that feeling by giving even anonymous commenters the option to edit comments after they click submit.

Don’t worry. They can’t edit comments forever (that would cause all kinds of problems).

Instead, they only have 5 minutes to edit their comment. This ensures that they have enough time to fix mistakes, but not so much time that they can change a comment’s meaning after other people have interacted.

To use this plugin, you simply install/activate it and it starts working right away – no configuration needed:

Simple Comment Editing
  • Save

Note: If you decide to use wpDiscuz, you don’t need this plugin because wpDiscuz already includes comment editing for anonymous users.

Use These WordPress Comment Plugins To Help Visitors Engage Better On Your Blog

As you can probably guess, I like Thrive Comments the best (otherwise I wouldn’t be using it on this site).

wpDiscuz is also another good option to add a lot of functionality to your comments section using one plugin.

And if you want some smaller enhancements, all of the other plugins add valuable features – they just don’t completely replace your comments section like Thrive Comments or wpDiscuz.

Want to talk about comments even more? Leave a comment and let’s see an active comments section in action!

Here are a few hand-picked articles for you to read next:

Was this helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!
  • Save
Authored By
A Blogger, Author and a speaker! Harsh Agrawal is recognized as a leader in digital marketing and FinTech space. Fountainhead of ShoutMeLoud, and a Speaker at ASW, Hero Mindmine, Inorbit, IBM, India blockchain summit. Also, an award-winning blogger.

18 thoughts on “7 Best Comment Plugins For WordPress Compared”

  1. Hey,

    I tried almost all comment plugins but the problem is in one of my blogs i get more than 500+ comments daily and 90% are spammy (e.g – Good post, Thanks for sharing)

    I can’t even figure out which comment is relevant because of the huge list.

    Is there any way to prevent this type of comment?

    Best regards

  2. Maria

    Great list. Thank you! I’d prefer the wpDiscuz plugin. I’ve used the plugin for 2 years and very happy with it. I highly recommend it.

  3. Obie

    Does Thrive allow commenters to edit and/or format their comments?

  4. robrt smith

    Thanks for this great list of the comment system. recently, I’m sticking with WordPress default comment system and use Askimet to stop comment spamming. it’s very useful for us

  5. Lawrence

    I can see you are recommending ThriveCommentd and WP Disqus. I was using WP Disqus on my website before.

    But, it was one SEO guru that discouraged me from the use that it will affect my website SEO.

    Please, how through is this

  6. Lesllie

    Do you still use the Thank Me Later plugin? The last time it was updated was over 3 years ago.

  7. Kavya Yadav

    Thanks for this great list of the comment system. Amazing stuff you have shared regarding comment blogging plug-ins. Currently, I am sticking with WordPress default comment system.

  8. Kingsley Felix

    this is great, my comment form already looks boring… i don’t mind adding this

  9. Adithya Shetty

    Hi Harsh,

    Great list of comment plugins. I’m hearing about thrive comments for the first time.

    Thanks for sharing!

  10. Santosh+Mahadik

    Hi Harsh ,
    Thanks for sharing such a valuable information. Currently, I am sticking with WordPress default comment system. I will definetly try other plugins as instructed by you.
    Santosh Mahadik

  11. Noman Sarwar

    In simple words, commenting made easier.
    Amazing stuff you have shared regarding comment blogging plug-ins. I recently was using commentluv, but now i am going to change it with wpDiscuz. Thanks for sharing

  12. Vishwajeet Kumar

    Hey Harsh,

    Thanks for this great list of the comment system. Currently, I am sticking with WordPress default comment system and use Askimet to prevent comment spamming. I have heard a lot of great things about Thrive comments and willing to give it a try. Thanks for the nice share.

    Have a Great day 🙂

  13. Pradeep Singh

    Hello Harsh,
    I am using Jetpack and maybe every Blogger But I was not aware About Jetpack Comments Now I am going to enable it.

  14. Emenike Emmanuel

    Hello Harsh,

    These are amazing plugins. I was just telling a friend how your blog theme just changed recently. I didn’t know this has been the power of Thrive theme.

    Thanks for sharing. I will try out, Thank Me Later because the features there as you mentioned are quite unique.



  15. Moses

    I use disqus. I tend to thinks its good as well.

  16. Freddy G. Cabrera

    Hey Harsh!

    These are good comment plugins for WordPress.

    I really like the Thrive Comments but found a few issues with it. I might have to work with it in the near future. I really like its features.

    I’m currently using the JetPack Comments and it is good. Can’t complain.

    I have not heard of a few of these that you are mentioning here. Will look more into them.

    Thank you so much for sharing this!

    Best regards! 😀

    1. Harsh Agrawal

      Yah, I saw your other comment about comment loading issue and I’m sure it’s an issue from Thrive comments. Hopefully it will be fixed with future updates. After your comment, I moved to basic WordPress comments feature but again enabled Thrive comments. I guess I’m kind of hooked to this one 🙂

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top