PayPal vs. Payoneer: Which one helped me earn an extra $1,700/year?

How do you usually receive payment overseas? If you are a blogger or an online marketer, chances are you’re using services like PayPal, Payoneer, and/or direct bank deposits. If you are, read on to learn something interesting that may help you save money.

Update: Pingpong is now cheaper than Payoneer and PayPal.

On 1st December 2016, ShoutMeLoud will be 8 years old. It also means that for the past 8 years, I have been making money online. During the initial days, I had limited options when it came to receiving overseas payment. This is why I never really worried about the “service” fees for sending or receiving funds.

Thanks to growing technology & new companies like Payoneer, Skrill, and Transferwise, I started to pay attention to these added fees.

In addition to Paypal, one of my other favorite payment services is Payoneer. They work a lot like PayPal where you can send and receive money overseas. But what really creates a difference between Payoneer & PayPal are the transfer fees.

In this guide, I’m going to highlight some of the differences between these services, and show you an example of the fees involved in one transaction done via PayPal & one done via Payoneer.

Payoneer vs. PayPal: Which service is best?

I started using PayPal in 2008 & Payoneer in 2013. Since then, I have been consistently using both the services to receive payment from the U.S., Europe, and many other parts of the world. Both services are reliable, excellent, and offer a great customer experience.

However, it would be wrong to call both services the same because both of them work very differently.

How does PayPal work?

When you create a PayPal account, the email account you signed up with will be used for sending and/or receiving payment. You can also link your bank account with PayPal so that you can take the money you’ve received in PayPal and put it into your local bank account.

When you want to receive payment, you simply share your PayPal address with the person, and he/she can send you money to your PayPal email address. Simple, isn’t it?

PayPal also supports a wide range of currencies which makes it easy to use in a worldwide situation.

supported-currencies-by-paypal
  • Save

Users (from many countries) can store money in their PayPal accounts. For example, if I send you $100, you can store that money in your PayPal account. For making future payments, you can use that $100 directly to make payment.

However, this feature is not available in many countries (like India) due to government regulations.

PayPal offers many other features such as a payment gateway which can be used to sell stuff online, run a membership site, and do various other activities.

Check out:

How does Payoneer work?

When you sign up for a Payoneer account, it will link to your local bank account. If you need one, Payoneer will give you a local bank account in the USA, Europe, the United Kingdom & Japan. When you have to receive payment, you simply share the bank account details given by Payoneer (found under your Payoneer dashboard).

One benefit of this is you won’t lose money due to multiple currency conversions.

Here’s an example:

  • You are from India & you receive a payment from Amazon U.S. using Payoneer. Amazon will deposit that money in USD into your Payoneer U.S. account, and then Payoneer will transfer & convert the money into your local currency, which you can withdraw into your bank account.

local-bank-account-payoneer
  • Save

The above example is crucial for you to understand, as this is one big step that helps you save a lot of money which you otherwise would lose due to double currency conversions.

Check out:

Which service should you use? PayPal vs. Payoneer

Both of them have their advantages & disadvantages in certain scenarios. You should really choose which one to use on a case by case basis.

Most affiliate marketing companies, ad agencies, and online services use PayPal.

In certain scenarios, when you have an alternative option to get paid using Payoneer, do the calculations and see if it makes sense.

In a majority of cases, Payoneer will help you save money.

But again, this only makes sense if Payoneer is a viable option.

Example: Receiving $2,300 from the United States (going to India)

PayPal:

Every month I receive $2,300/month from a direct advertiser (detailed in our monthly income reports). Until last month, I used PayPal to receive the money. Here is the screenshot from my PayPal account:

fees-charged-by-paypal
  • Save

PayPal converted USD into INR before transferring the money into my local bank account. This is where PayPal used their own conversion rates (rather than the market standard) & I ended up receiving:

$2,198.5 * 65.04 = INR 142,990

Payoneer:

With Payoneer, I received the complete $2,300 & the conversion rate was the market standard:

payoneer-fees-usd-to-inr
  • Save

Amount received into my bank account: INR 152,629

The Difference:

For receiving $2,300 from the U.S. to India, while using Payoneer, I saved about $142/transaction.

In one year, that’s $1,704! 

$1,700 a year is indeed a considerable amount of money which I was otherwise losing by using PayPal to receive this money.

Conclusion

As I said above, you should have & use both PayPal and Payoneer accounts. Whenever possible, you may want to consider using Payoneer to receive payment.

Unlike PayPal, Payoneer offers services in select currencies. If you are receiving money in USD, Euro, GBP, or Japanese Yen, you should try using Payoneer & see if it helps you to save money or not.

Create PayPal account || Create Payoneer account

In my testing, Payoneer definitely helped me to save a big chunk of money over PayPal.

If you have the chance to switch to Payoneer for receiving and/or sending certain payments, you should not miss the opportunity to do so.

What are your thoughts on PayPal vs. Payoneer? Has Payoneer saved you money? Let me know in the comments below!

Don’t forget to share this post!

Here are a few hand-picked tutorials for you to read next:

Subscribe on YouTube

  • Save
Authored By
A Blogger, Author and a speaker! Harsh Agrawal is recognized as a leader in digital marketing and FinTech space. Fountainhead of ShoutMeLoud, and a Speaker at ASW, Hero Mindmine, Inorbit, IBM, India blockchain summit. Also, an award-winning blogger.

54 thoughts on “PayPal vs. Payoneer: Which one helped me earn an extra $1,700/year?”

  1. Sathish Arumugam

    I don’t find out more about Payoneer, but after reading this blog, I think Payoneer will be better when compared to PayPal. I will soon try out Payoneer soon and will share my experience too. I was searching for an alternative to PayPal. Because my online e-commerce website are facing many problems with Paypal, instantly my account got restricted, and I think this issues will overcome with Payoneer

  2. Hi Harish,

    Thanks for writing such an excellent detailed article about Payoneer. I have signed up for its service after reading your article. And you have mentioned that there is no charge unlike PayPal for every transaction made from Payoneer to local Indian bank (USD to INR) However, in Payoneer’s website, it mentioned that a 2% conversion rate would apply for each transaction made? Could you please clarify this confusion.

  3. Rabins Sharma Lamichhane

    I had been using Paypal for a long time even though I’d Payoneer too. When the Payoneer was first launched I was not sure if it’s gonna work or not. But later I found if you know how it works Payoneer is quite good. I love to buy domain names using the card’s details when by using Paypal we are not able to purchase. So, my experience is Payoneer Master Card I save approx $5 on each domain and other discounted products.

  4. Dheeraj Singh

    Hi Harsh! Thanks for sharing such a useful Information. It really helped me for Saving Extra Money.

  5. Hello Harsh ,
    Yes by reading this article i am agree with you .
    My last payment on paypal was 1200$ in which they cut approx 100$ and in same time i received 400$ on payoneer and there is no fees by them.
    Paypal has best refund policy but payoneer doesn’t .That’s the issue if i am a buyer .
    Thanks

  6. Payoneer is very good. I have been using a PayPal account in the USA that I bought from Auction Essistance since PayPal isn’t supported in my country Pakistan. PayPal eats a lot of fees which is why I switched to Payoneer.

  7. SignAdvertising

    I agree with you that Payoneer is more beneficial than PayPal. But this is also a matter of the fact that PayPal is almost universal accepted.

    Also, Payoneer sometimes doesn’t allow individual payment for some account.

  8. Yeah I agree, Payoneer is better than Paypal. Paypal cut more commission than the Payonner and take much time. It’s just an old brand and it does not always true that old one should be the best one.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
112 Shares
[i]
[i]
[i]
[i]
Share via
Copy link