Authored By
Author and owner of UniversityZero.info
    • Thats Matt Cutts point of view. There are a few blogs, that have dofollow and have managed to maintain a good readership and doing just fine with the spams using Akismet.

      The final decision for your blog will have to be yours.

      • Shocky,

        Matt told about spam things and I also agree with you that Akismet is just fine for those.
        But still will it be fine to keep the comments dofollow? for example, consider a post that have 30 comments. So if comment author’s links are dofollow the page will have 30 outbound links. is it ok? As you said,

        “Personally, I wouldn’t like to have a dofollow comment section as it would of now use. Since thousands of outgoing links would mean that my page rank is divided to insignificant parts and shared with each one.”

        I agree with your this comment, but in reply to my previous comment, you also said,

        “Thats Matt Cutts point of view. There are a few blogs, that have dofollow and have managed to maintain a good readership and doing just fine with the spams using Akismet.”

        Which indicates that you also have some point in support to keep comments dofollow. I am confused.

        The final decision is obviously the blog owners but I think we can have a good discussion. What do you think?

        Harsh, What’s your opinion?

        • My intentions behind making this post was not to influence anyone to make a choice. I only wanted to put forward the points that one should keep in mind while making the choice.

          If look at it clearly, it is obvious that there are only negatives of dofollow if the comments are not moderated properly(causing excessive spam). Therefore, it is not as easy a decision as it may seem. Since it is always nice to give back to your readers, a dofollow comment section is a great initiative to keep them coming back.

          I, after doing much research relating to the subject, would recommend using the plugin LinkLove(http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/link-love/) which allows you set a certain number of approved comments required by a a user before he/she is granted dofollow privileges.

          Hope this helps out clear all your doubts.

      • Commenting on blogs demonstrates that you’re an active member of your niche, you’re passionate enough to participate in conversations related to your area of expertise, and you’re intelligent enough to add value to conversations in your space.

      • I am also same thinking that decision is totally depending on yours hand that keep the blog dofollow or nofollow

      • ah! well my comment section would be nofollow because i get a lot of spam links daily close to 100, akismet stops many but sometimes you don’t get to check the link people are using, i may use a top commentors widget.

  • Personally, I think its only fair that if someone is contributing to your site that hey have the ability to be followed. I don’t like the stifle and suppression of my clients. They have a message to get out just as important as I do.

    • Yes, and its always good share the link juice with your readers, giving them all the more reason to comment and hence build a community around your blog.
      With that said, it is important to have a fool-proof spam protection inorder to protect the blog’s reputation.

  • I always have this confusion of whether to make comments Dofollow or Nofollow. As you said it’s upto the admin to decide. Good post 🙂

  • Interesting Read. We’re considering making the switch to dofollow but it’s a tough decision. We already get enough spam, but akismet handles most of it. I’m curious if you do go to a dofollow method, should you let it be known? I see there are sites out there that allow you to list your dofollow blog, but then it appears that you’re really going to be attracting spammers more than anything.

  • i really didn’t know that my blog was set on NoFollow on default. i just found out a few days ago and i was still thinking if i should go ahead and remove it or what. but i made my decision. i’m removing it and i’ll be officially a do-follow blog in a couple of minutes.

  • I completely agree that spam comments can become a troublesome task, but it’s only the larger web pages that are going to have to deal with so much spam that it becomes a problem. On the whole, most sites will easily be able to manage spam comments. On the flip side, the links formed via comments are important for smaller web pages looking for a boost, which is why I think do-follow comments are so vital as a way of building links across the web for small sites. From my perspective, as a young website trying to grow, it’s a democratic way of doing things – the bigger, “richer” sites must do a little more in order for the smaller, “impoverished” sites, in order to provide them with opportunity!

  • It is better to make a comment “nofollow” rather than making it a “dofollow” since its a time taking task to manage spams..

  • I am pretty new in blogging but not in do-follow stuff i would rather keep my blog no-follow because spammers always try’s to find a do-follow blog where they can spam with their comments . Or the better way is to keep facebook comment plugin no links allowed no spammers gona comment .

  • I still don’t know Harsh. I get these seriously varying opinions and how it gets handled on dofollow or nofollow on comment sections. Frankly, if I comment allot on a blogging site they are probably already heavily linked all over mine and domain referred already with a dofollow, which is allot stronger then a comment section back link whether its a dofollow or a nofollow.

    So, I am not feeling much guilt when I go there and fully read and comment. Whatever link juice I am taking, I feel if I can, I am going to return it in some way and more even if they don’t show up on mine to comment. That is just how I personally play it. If I am going to comment allot on a bloggers site, then whether they come and comment or not on mine, they will be linked directly all over the place that is relevant to theirs. How good is that referral? Getting a little bit better every day.

    Dofollow or Nofollow on the comment section though. Things like comment luv or not. Don’t know because I can’t get anything close to a consistency of response from some very popular bloggers.

  • I just started getting comments on my blog and I am wondering about the dofollow / nofollow.

    When I installed my wordpress I never looked into it but now I would like to know if my blog has dofollow enabled or disabled? How can I check it?

    I want to set my blog as nofollow for a obvious reasons posted on this article.

      • Hi, Harsh
        Can you tell me it’s means below?
        Since outgoing link means you are sharing your Page Rank, you have to be careful about the quality of the sites you are linking to. Otherwise, the reputation of you blog will be affected.
        I can’t understand Please help me.

  • Hi Shocky,

    Very nice post to clear the concept of dofollow and nofollow. I am learning blogging and shoutmeloud.com is my main source of knowledge apart from other sites.

    After reading the post and comments I have reached the conclusion of keeping the comments Dofollow as it will encourage people to comment, give and take backlinks.
    Obviously, we will have to be careful with moderation of comments but in order to gain something you have to give something.

    In my opinion, Dofollow comments have more advantages than disadvantages.

    Harsh, please tell are Shoutmeloud’s comments Dofollow or Nofollow?

    Thanks.

  • >